I know, it’s not the earliest of reviews. The super-smart bloke Taran Ardash beat me to it, and so did all of those self-consciously smart critics who are abundant in the Bollywood-land. But to have come back from the movie and go through the horrendous trashing the movie subsequently received, I decided to lay back on the lazy chair a while and come back with a review nearly a week after I actually watched the movie.
Jhootha Hi Sahi, in my opinion, didn’t feel like a bad movie- so I quite frankly can’t understand some critics’ verdict that Jhootha Hi Sahi ‘is so bad that it is good’. And I can’t help but to think that John Abraham’s exerted acting in most of his prior movies has become his own biggest enemy as the critics find it savory to bash him no matter what he does.
And oh yah, how could I forget, one reviewer even though it’s ‘cool’ to rate AR Rahman’s music as 1 out of 5 while rating the movie. Well, these folks would definitely rate ‘I Hate Luv Storys’ album as being 3 out of 5, at least.
Here are some straight facts- if you really want to see John Abraham looking comfortable and at home in a character that he is enacting, then watch Jhootha Hi Sahi. And when you walk into the movie, you get laughs, not because they are slapstick, but because they seem realistic, brings a group of people together, and is mostly drawn from dumbfounded reactions that the characters give when they are at their wits’ ends.
Why, I guess the lot who are bashing it would find Akshay Kumar haggling down the street extremely funny but would find a group of friends on a silent London street and their daily comedic travails as extremely unfunny.
For one, Jhootha Hi Sahi’s plot is believable. Of course, don’t tell me John jumping over the Tower Bridge during the climax is a scene that you expected to be realistic- but the events and the plot unfolds logically and the individuals fall in love gradually rather than just springing into love all of a sudden. Don’t complaint to me that the characters don’t fall in love instantly- because- do you fall in love as instant as that? If you think life is just like Kuch Kuch Hota Hai, then you are in a different league altogether.
JHS is a film that is baked in the foundation of reality and has a bit of fairytale sprinkled on top, so that you get what you ask for all the time- entertainment. At least I got my entertainment.
John Abraham, for once, performed very well- and his stammering was very believable indeed and not laughable like how some people suggest. Pakhi Tyrewala is decent, but I can’t help but to notice her glowing smile is a bit over-used at times that doesn’t fit the scene too well. But apart from that, it was still a solid performance and there’s not too many things wrong about it- unless you are obsessed with aneroxic Kareenas and Katrinas and Priyankas shaking their toned hips and looking too perfect on the screen. For once, you have a heroine who looks very much like a girl you could find in your life- with all her complications and delay in decision-making- and for me that’s a darn good thing.
Everyone else who performed as the friends did well, even though the track between the unwed pregnant mother Aliya and her Japanese-British boyfriend does leave a bit clueless at the end, something like, that’s all? But hey, we can overlook that on the larger scale.
ARR’s music is as fresh as they come. The beauty of London runs in tandem with his minimal BGM, and his fresh music composition, which have similar connotations to the previous Abbas- ARR flick Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na.
Though extremely convincing as a jealousy-infused jerk, Madhavan can stay out of such roles, because it just doesn’t sit well why he needs to take the effort to make a special appearance just to play the role of a complete jerk.
The script has its loopholes, but people could give Pakhi Tyrewala a break- it’s her first attempt at a script and definitely she wasn’t going to get everything right at the first go. But at least with Abbas’ direction, JHS is quite a decent flick to go for. So for me, I’d say it was still worth my tickets. Believe at you own expense those who say it’s not worth a ticket. If you watch it with your family, or better yet, a group of friends, you’ll find the relevance and have your laughs.
All in all, JHS is an imperfect yet enjoyable film. Period.
Rating: 7/10


